DISQUS

soxgal · 3 months ago

We're just starting to transition to sippy cups and despite claims of "no leak" seals, my son has managed to chew through every kind of top there is and make the cups leak. We can't figure out if the ones with handles or without are best. Should we get cups with straws or without? I think we're just going to go with the old Tupperware standby from when I was a child. I think I still have all the cups and seals I "borrowed" from my parents when I moved away from home more than 15 years ago.

maxkalehoff · 3 months ago

I never thought of the chewing issue, but, indeed, a real challenge.

juliette · 3 months ago

Max- of much greater concern than incompatible parts is plastics. Choose a brand that makes metal or glass cups. At the very least, keep those plastics out of the dishwasher.

maxkalehoff · 3 months ago

Juliette, that's a very good point. We've actually been purchasing the "safe
plastics," but agree...we'd be better off without any plastics. We'll have
to do something about that.

Daniel M. Clark · 3 months ago

Metal or glass? For a toddler? Metal maybe, if you're willing to put up with dents, but my 8 month old routinely drops his sippy cup on the floor. A glass sippy cup would be a thrice daily disaster.

After someone brought it up on my podcast a few months ago, we switched to BPA-free plastic sippy cups.

Daniel M. Clark · 3 months ago

Good post, Max. We try to stay away from cups that have more parts than just bottom/lid/valve, but we do have a couple that have 3-4 piece straws that need to be assembled. Pretty silly, really.

We must shop in the same place - we have that Diego cup, too. And if I'm not mistaken, the one to the left of it is a Dora cup? That style cup worked out for us really well when my daughter graduated past the cups with handles. Awesome for taking in the car.

Lydia Sugarman · 3 months ago

Gee, while "the industry" is standardizing sippy cup design to one design standard, why not just appoint one company to manufacture all sippy cups to that standard?

Doesn't that sound silly? But, what you're suggesting with your first option is to kill competition and subsequently, capitalism.

Think about why you've bought or been given sippy cups of different design. Different people think different designs work better than others. You experiment until we find something that works just for you.

I, for one, do not want to live in a world of white Priuses and khaki unisex coveralls. I want red Ferreris and dresses by Pucci, too!

So, put away the ones that don't do it for you or give them away and just use the one design that works for you and your toddler. But, please, leave me with lots of choices in sippy cups and in life!

maxkalehoff · 3 months ago

I beg to differ. I'm certainly not asking to kill capitalism. I
sarcastically suggested some mild cooperation to address a tragedy of the
commons. Industries (and their competitors within) very often work together
on standards in order to reduce market friction and thereby grow the entire
market. The theory is that all boats rise or sink with the tide. In
practicality, I concur that won't happen in the sippy cup industry. I think
picking just one make of sippy cup is the most feasible solution. In the
spirit of capitalism, let the best competitor win. Further in spirit of
capitalism, let some ambitious inventor create a better mousetrap...I mean,
sippy cup.

Daniel M. Clark · 3 months ago

That's more than a little extreme, Lydia. Many industries, healthy industries, have standards for products across the board. Companies realized that parts of a product can be standardized so the consumers can easily work with a range of products - the overall products themselves can be very, very different. Think of the headphones that plug into your iPod or CD player. There are hundreds to choose from, all very different, but they all use the same standard plug to connect to your player.

Nobody is suggesting khaki unisex coveralls.

maxkalehoff · 3 months ago

Good point Daniel. Another example would be even vitamins and drugs. Different competing brands, but interoperable.

Shai Berger · 3 months ago

I give thanks regularly to the unsung standards in everyday products. Aren't you glad all rolls of toilet paper and paper towels have the same width?

maxkalehoff · 3 months ago

Shai, great point. Provided this is part parenting blog, I guess I can get
away with expressing my appreciation for standards in birth control devices
as well.

Brian LoCicero · 3 months ago

We solved this in our house. We only buy Sesame Street and Disney ones. Only TWO parts. Cup and Lid, that's it. Of course, our little guy isn't working the straws yet, but I think we just won't ever let him.

Agree with soxgal though, that these two piecers do leak a bit when your child heaves them across the room and/or chews on the mouthpiece endlessly whilst teething.

maxkalehoff · 3 months ago

A solution to the few minor leaks with the two-piece cup would be to
limit the fluids to clear (milk would be the exception). A few drops
of clear liquids? That's toerable.